Home » Santa Clarita News » Crime » Court » Westfield Valencia Town Center Listed In Lawsuit Against L.A. County To Re-Open Indoor Malls
By Sophia Lesseos

Westfield Valencia Town Center Listed In Lawsuit Against L.A. County To Re-Open Indoor Malls

The Westfield Valencia Town Center is listed as a plaintiff in a lawsuit against Los Angeles County for the “unlawful and unjustifiable” decision not to allow indoor malls to re-open despite state health officials giving the go-ahead.

On Monday, Westfield filed a class-action lawsuit in the United States District Court against the County of Los Angeles and several public officials over the decision to keep indoor malls closed due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

The lawsuit is alleging that the county “forced hundreds of businesses in indoor malls to close, kept thousands of county residents out of work, caused millions of dollars in lost wages and revenue, and brought many businesses to the brink of collapse—without offering a single valid, science- or health-based reason for their actions.”

“In doing so, the County and its officials have overtly discriminated against businesses in indoor malls and their employees without any rational basis whatsoever, trampling the constitutional rights of those businesses and individuals,” the suit reads.

The Westfield Valencia Town Center is listed as a plaintiff in the suit, as their indoor operations have remained closed for the most part since mid-March, with the exception of a brief period in the summer when indoor malls were allowed to re-open.

The Valencia mall is over one million square feet in size, and employs an estimated 3,700 people.

“Valencia Town Center meticulously analyzed its hourly capacity tracking data from 2019 and confirmed that the mall has more than enough space to reopen while complying with social distancing guidelines,” the suit reads.

In addition to the County of Los Angeles, the suit also lists the County Board of Supervisors, County Health Officer Dr. Muntu Davis, County Public Health Director Dr. Barbara Ferrer and Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva as defendants.

“The County has refused to follow the State’s science-based approach,” the suit reads. “On September 2, 2020, Dr. Davis, the County of Los Angeles Health Officer, ordered that, in this county, all indoor portions and operations of indoor malls and shopping centers must ‘remain closed to the public until further notice.’ That action breaks sharply from the County’s previous practice of aligning its business restrictions with those imposed by the State.”

See Related: No Labor Day ‘Surge’ Of Coronavirus Cases Expected In Los Angeles County

On Aug. 28, the California Department of Public Health announced that indoor operations for malls could resume with restrictions in counties throughout the state, including those in the state’s “Tier 1” of the re-opening process such as Los Angeles County.

However, in a Health Order issued by Davis on Sept. 2 indoor malls were defined as “Lower-Risk Businesses,” which were not allowed to open when the issue was ordered. Other businesses listed in this category include “large department stores, small retailers, and hair salons and barbershops,” all of which have since been permitted to re-open indoor operations in a limited capacity.

“The County’s forced closure of indoor malls and shopping centers stands in stark contrast to its treatment of virtually every other retail establishment, including large and small scale retailers and hair salons and barbershops not inside malls—all of which were permitted to reopen immediately and operate at a minimum at 25 percent capacity, in accordance with statewide guidelines,” the suit reads.

The suit further alleges that there is “absolutely no evidence to support the County’s unique and discriminatory treatment of indoor malls and shopping centers,” and that such treatment is “perverse because the County has seen steady improvement in its COVID-19 transmission metrics (…) but has not bothered to reconsider its position.”

“There is no data showing that indoor malls are any less safe than the large retail stores that have been open for months or the ‘outdoor’ malls that the County has permitted to reopen. Nor has the County or any other Defendant offered a data-based explanation—or any reason whatsoever—for this differential treatment,” the suit reads. “This continued unreasoned and unjustified policy has needlessly shuttered hundreds of businesses and thrown thousands of employees out of work, devastating those businesses, their employees, and their families.”


Sponsored Articles


Do you have a news tip? Call us at (661) 298-1220, or send an email to newstip@hometownstation.com. Don’t miss a thing. Get breaking KHTS Santa Clarita News Alerts delivered right to your inbox. Report a typo or error, email Corrections@hometownstation.com

KHTS FM 98.1 and AM 1220 is Santa Clarita’s only local radio station. KHTS mixes in a combination of news, traffic, sports, and features along with your favorite adult contemporary hits. Santa Clarita news and features are delivered throughout the day over our airwaves, on our website and through a variety of social media platforms. Our KHTS national award-winning daily news briefs are now read daily by 34,000+ residents. A vibrant member of the Santa Clarita community, the KHTS broadcast signal reaches all of the Santa Clarita Valley and parts of the high desert communities located in the Antelope Valley. The station streams its talk shows over the web, reaching a potentially worldwide audience. Follow @KHTSRadio on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

KHTS AM 1220 & FM 98.1 - Santa Clarita Radio - Santa Clarita News

Westfield Valencia Town Center Listed In Lawsuit Against L.A. County To Re-Open Indoor Malls

9 comments

  1. WTF is wrong with you? I could care less if the mall ever reopened. The fact that these idiots have filed a lawsuit is …….I have no words.

    • Stay home and eat some more McDonald’s, smoke a joint, vape, Mark. The high risk should take precautions. Let the people who are not living in fear provide for their family and pay their rent/mortgage. Selfish prick.

    • Do you mean the idiots who were working to put food on the table? Or do you mean the idiots who shut down the economy due to a virus that had a 99.9999 Survival rate unless you had two or more pre-existing conditions? As stated below, if you do not feel safe stay at home, actually please never leave your house again because it is not safe. As you can see in the news today, somebody died in a car accident, maybe we should lower the speed limit to 25 mph, do you really need to go faster than that? Or maybe ban all transportation altogether.

    • Mark, We can’t live in fear forever. This is not the Black Plague. Worse things are happening to people by living in an unrealistic fear over Covid. The science and numbers do not warrant the overreaction our “leaders” are having…unless it magically goes away after November 3rd. Hmmmm…I hope that is not the reason for extending this on and on and on….

  2. Yeah Mark, those 3700 people should all just lose their jobs, the businesses all just close down until there are no cases. (nevermind mind the > 99% COVID survivability rate).

    If you dont feel safe, dont go. Stay home. Simple as that. But to continue keeping the world closed when the vast majority of the population are minimally impacted makes no sense. At-risk people are always welcome to continue to stay home.

  3. Clearly, the Town Center is looking out for the interests of money over the safety of its workers and customers. This is an unreasonable hierarchical mistake and seemingly against biblica teachings. I for one wil no longer shop there in the future as I cannot trust other aspects of my safety whike under their stewardship.

  4. Give me the choice, to shop or not.

  5. Newsom had to get Aunt Nancy’s approval before he could throw us a few crumbs.

  6. I know the governor shut down the state or the DNC rather shut down to state after the California primaries didn’t see the results they wanted boohoo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About Michael Brown

Michael Brown has lived in Santa Clarita his whole life. Graduating from Saugus High School in 2016, he continued to stay local by attending The Master’s University, where he achieved a Bachelor's Degree in Communication. Michael joined KHTS in January of 2018 as a news intern, and has since gone on to become the News Director for the KHTS Newsroom. Since joining KHTS, Michael has covered many breaking news stories (both on scene and on air), interviewed dozens of prominent state and federal political figures, and interacted with hundreds of residents from Santa Clarita. When he is not working, Michael enjoys spending time with his family, as well as reading any comic book he can get his hands on.